Discipline Notice - Nicholas A. Fay

License Number: 47603
Member Name: Nicholas A. Fay
Discipline Detail
Action: Disbarment
Effective Date: 1/25/2023
RPC: 1.15A - Safeguarding Property
1.16 - Declining or Terminating Representation
1.3 - Diligence
1.4 - Communication
1.5 - Fees
3.2 - Expediting Litigation
8.1 - Bar Admission Matters
8.4 (c) - Dishonesty, Fraud, Deceit or Misrepresentation
8.4 (l) - Violate ELCs
Discipline Notice: Hearing Officer's Decision
Disciplinary Board Order Declining Sua Sponte Review and Adopting Hearing Officer’s Recommendation
Supreme Court Order
Description: Nicholas A. Fay (WSBA No. 47603, admitted 2014) of Bellingham, was disbarred, effective 1/25/2023, by order of the Washington Supreme Court. Fay’s conduct violated the following Rules of Professional Conduct: 1.3 (Diligence), 1.4 (Communication), 1.5 (Fees), 1.15A (Safeguarding Property), 1.16 (Declining or Terminating Representation), 3.2 (Expediting Litigation), 8.1 (Bar Admission and Disciplinary Matters), 8.4(c) (Dishonesty, Fraud, Deceit or Misrepresentation), 8.4(l) ELC Violation..
In relation to his representation of a client A in a property dispute, and client B in a landlord-tenant dispute, the Hearing Officer recommended, and the Supreme Court ordered, that Fay be disbarred following a hearing. Fay was found to have violated the Rules of Professional Conduct by: 1) failing to keep client A reasonably informed about the status of their case and by failing to promptly comply with client A’s reasonable requests for information; 2) failing to act with reasonable diligence in representing client A and in handling their case; 3) by charging and collecting an unreasonable fee of more than $18,000 from client A; 4) by failing to respond to client A’s grievance; 5) failing to promptly provide client B an accounting of their funds upon client B’s request; 6) failing to respond to requests to explain IOLTA account overdrafts, failing to appear for a deposition, and failing to produce documents in response to a subpoena; 7) writing and depositing checks totaling $17,000 made out to Fay, without sufficient funds to meet those checks; and 8) failing to communicate with client A and client B, failing to provide a way for clients to obtain information about their legal matters, and by failing to maintain professional channels of communication by which Fay could be located or corresponded with by clients and others (such as the WSBA and process servers), Fay abandoned his practice without providing for his clients’ needs.
Erica Temple acted as disciplinary counsel. Nicholas A. Fay represented himself. Joseph M. Mano, Jr. was the hearing officer. The online version of Washington State Bar News contains links to the following documents: Hearing Officer’s Recommendation; Disciplinary Board Order Declining Sua Sponte Review and Adopting Hearing Officer’s Recommendation; and Washington Supreme Court Order.


In some cases, discipline search results will not reveal all disciplinary action relating to a Washington licensed legal professional, and may not display links to the official decision documents. Click the "Important Information" button below for further details.

Important Information +


This discipline search accesses notices of disciplinary action since 1984, and for cases decided in 2013 or later, also generally includes the official decision documents. The search does not contain pre-1984 notices or records, and may not contain the official decision documents in cases decided before 2013. To obtain other records of discipline, including pre-1984 discipline documents, please make a public records request.

The action listed on the discipline notice does not in all cases reflect the current status of the legal professional's license. Check the Legal Directory for current status information.